SEO & GEO

What Is an SEO Site Audit?

An SEO site audit is a health check for your website. Somebody, or some software, goes through the site looking for anything that stops search engines from finding, understanding or trusting your pages, then writes up what they found and what to do about it.

That’s the whole idea. It feels bigger because audits come with scores, colour-coded charts, and reports that run to eighty pages, and it’s easy to lose the thread. A good audit ends with a short list of things to fix, in a sensible order. A bad one ends with a number and a feeling of guilt.

How This Differs From a General Website Review

If you’ve read the plain English audit checklist on this site, you’ll know it looks at whether a website is doing its job for a business: is the message clear, does it work on a phone, can a customer get in touch. Useful, and a good starting point.

An SEO audit is narrower and more technical. It asks whether search engines can reach your pages, whether they understand them, and whether anything is quietly holding the site back. You can have a lovely website that passes the first check with flying colours and still fail the second. It happens more often than you’d think.

The Order I’d Work In

Auditors differ, and tools present things in all sorts of ways, but this sequence makes sense because each step depends on the one before. There’s no point polishing a page title if Google can’t see the page.

1. Can Search Engines Find and Index Your Pages?

Start here, always. If a page isn’t in Google’s index, nothing else about it matters. Check that your robots.txt file isn’t blocking anything important, that no page has a stray noindex tag, and that your XML sitemap exists and lists the pages you actually want found.

Google Search Console is the best place to see this. Its page indexing report shows which pages are indexed, which aren’t, and, usefully, why.

2. Is the Site Technically Healthy?

This is the plumbing. Broken links, redirect chains where one address bounces through three others before landing, pages returning errors, a mix of secure and insecure addresses, duplicate versions of the same page. None of these is dramatic alone, but they pile up.

Speed and mobile usability belong here too. Core Web Vitals, Google’s measures of loading speed, responsiveness and visual stability, are worth checking page by page, not just on the homepage.

3. Is Each Page Doing Its Job?

Now you look at the pages themselves. Does each one have its own title and meta description? A single clear main heading? Content that actually answers what a searcher wanted? Are two of your pages competing for the same search, so neither wins?

Thin pages with a few lines of text, duplicate content and missing image descriptions turn up here as well. Of these, mismatched content, a page that doesn’t deliver what its title promises, usually matters most.

4. Is the Site Sensibly Organised?

Internal links are how you tell search engines which pages matter. An audit checks for orphan pages that nothing links to, important pages buried five clicks deep, and menus that make the structure harder to follow than it needs to be.

5. Does Anyone Trust It?

This looks outside the site. Who links to you, and are those links from relevant, reputable places? For a local business, this also means checking the Google Business Profile and whether your name, address, and phone number match everywhere they appear online.

6. Is It Ready for AI Search?

This is a newer addition. Google says that optimising for its AI features is still SEO, so most of the work is the same as above. What’s worth checking is that you haven’t accidentally blocked crawlers you’d want to let in, that your key pages are indexable, and that your content says something original instead of repeating what everyone else says.

A Local Example

Imagine a plumber in Witney who has just had a new website built. The homepage looks great, the speed is fine, and the phone number is right at the top. Three weeks later, the page for Oxford callouts is nowhere in Google. An audit would find the cause in about two minutes: the developer left a noindex tag on during testing, and nobody removed it.

That’s a typical audit result. Not a dramatic strategy change, just one small, specific, easily fixed mistake that was costing real enquiries.

Tools You Can Use

  • Google Search Console is free, comes straight from Google and should always be your first stop
  • Bing Webmaster Tools is also free, and its own site scan sometimes flags things Google’s tools don’t
  • PageSpeed Insights and Google Lighthouse check speed, accessibility and best practices page by page
  • Screaming Frog crawls your site like a search engine and has a free version with a limit on the number of URLs
  • Paid platforms such as Ahrefs and Semrush run scheduled audits and track your health score over time

You don’t need all of them. For a small site, Search Console plus one crawler covers nearly everything.

Reading the Results Without Panicking

Almost every audit tool produces alarming numbers on a perfectly decent site. A crawler might report four hundred missing image descriptions and one noindex tag on your homepage. One of those is an afternoon of tidying. The other is a disaster. The tool won’t always tell you which.

So sort what you find by impact. Anything stopping pages from being indexed comes first. Then broken or erroring pages, then page-level improvements such as titles and content, and last the cosmetic items. A health score of 100 isn’t the goal, and chasing it can waste weeks on changes nobody will ever notice.

How Often to Do One

A full audit makes sense before and after a redesign or migration, when a site’s traffic drops unexpectedly, or when you take on an SEO adviser. Otherwise, a deep look once a year plus a quick monthly glance at Search Console is plenty for most small business sites.

A Quick Audit Checklist

☐  Check key pages are indexed in Search Console, and find out why any aren’t

☐  Look for noindex tags and robots.txt rules that block the wrong things

☐  Fix broken links and long redirect chains

☐  Make sure every important page has its own title, meta description and main heading

☐  Check Core Web Vitals and mobile usability on more than the homepage

☐  Link important pages from other pages, and find any orphans

☐  Confirm your Google Business Profile and contact details are consistent

☐  Write down what you found, ranked by impact, and fix the top three first

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does an SEO site audit take?

A quick check of a small site can be done in an afternoon. A thorough audit of a larger site, with analysis and a written plan, can take days. Most of the time goes on interpreting the results, not running the tools.

Can I audit my own site?

Yes, at least the basics. Search Console, a free crawler and a methodical checklist will find most common problems. It helps to bring in outside eyes for a migration, a sudden drop in traffic or anything where the cause isn’t obvious.

How much does an SEO audit cost?

It varies widely. Some tools give you a basic report for free, and professional audits range from a modest fee for a small site to considerably more for a large one. Be wary of any audit that is mostly an automated report with a sales pitch attached.

What’s the difference between an SEO audit and a website audit?

A website audit looks at how well the site serves your business and visitors overall. An SEO audit focuses on whether search engines can find, understand and trust it. They overlap, and the best results come from doing both.

Will fixing everything in an audit improve my rankings?

Not by itself. An audit removes obstacles, but rankings also depend on content quality, competition and authority. Think of it as clearing the road before you start the journey.

Want Someone to Look Over Your Site?

If you’d like a second pair of eyes on what’s holding your site back in search, get in touch, and we can talk it through, no obligation and no hard sell.

Keep reading

Further reading

Should I Put SEO on My CV?

Yes, provided you can genuinely back it up if asked about it. SEO is a widely recognised, in-demand skill, and listing it can genuinely strengthen a CV for a relevant role. The mistake many people make isn’t mentioning it; it’s how vaguely they mention it, which can undermine credibility rather than build it. This article […]

24 September 2026 · 4 min read

Are SEO Services Worth It?

Are SEO services worth it? It is a fair question, and one that deserves a straight answer rather than the carefully worded non-answer most SEO providers give when asked directly. The honest answer is: it depends. But not in a vague or evasive way. It depends on specific, identifiable things that you can evaluate for […]

2 July 2026 · 7 min read